Tithely vs Planning Center Giving Fees on a $100 Gift

By Jake Thornhill•November 10, 2026•8 min read

Ministry Automation makes and sells the prompt packs linked on this page.

Two practical ways to get started with AI in your ministry

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

$6.99 · one-time purchase

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

$24.99 one-time · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →
A hand placing an offering envelope into a knitted red offering bag held in a church aisle, with a person in vestments holding the bag and people seated in pews behind.
Placing an offering envelope into an offering bag during a church service. A general photo, not a screenshot of Tithely or Planning Center. Credit: Korean Anglican's Offering Bags, photograph by Alvis Jean, 7 April 2024. Licensed under Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/deed.en). Resized for web; no other changes.

Tithely and Planning Center: last checked Nov 9, 2026 ET. Who runs this fee comparison | Corrections to the Tithely and Planning Center numbers

Which charges less on a $100 gift, Tithely or Planning Center Giving?

On the fees each vendor lists, Planning Center Giving charges less. By card, the fee on a $100 gift is $2.45 at Planning Center (2.15% + $0.30) and $3.20 at Tithely (2.9% + $0.30). By bank transfer (ACH), it is $0.30 at Planning Center and $1.30 at Tithely. These are the rates on each vendor's own pricing page on Nov 9, 2026. Fees are not the whole cost, so read the limits below.

Key takeaways

  • Planning Center Giving (US) lists 2.15% + $0.30 per card transaction, 0% + $0.30 by ACH bank transfer, and 1.5% extra for international cards.
  • Tithely lists 2.9% + $0.30 by card, 1% + $0.30 by ACH, and 3.5% + $0.30 for AMEX.
  • On a $100 gift: Tithely card $3.20, Tithely ACH $1.30, Planning Center card $2.45, Planning Center ACH $0.30.
  • Tithely's Free Giving plan is $0 a month, and processing fees still apply.
  • We did not test either product. The review counts below are hand counts.

What we read before writing this

This page is built on public pages, not on our own trial. We did not sign up for either product. On Nov 9, 2026 we read each vendor's pricing page, 25 Tithe.ly reviews on Capterra and 10 Planning Center Giving reviews on G2.

Tithe.ly on Capterra. Capterra gives Tithe.ly 4.7 across 693 reviews, on a page marked as last updated Oct 21, 2026. We read 25 of them, dated Feb 2025 to May 21, 2026. Money comes up in two ways. About 6 reviewers praise low cost or value, and one says percentage fees are heavy on very large gifts. Three complain that deposits to the bank are slow. Overall, about 20 of the 25 are positive, 4 are mixed and 1 is negative, and the negative one comes from a donor, not a church. Capterra tags one entry "Review Source" and does not show the source. Another entry reads like pasted text, so we set it aside as unreliable.

Planning Center Giving on G2. The page shows 4.5 from 19 reviews. The 10 we read run from Jan 2019 to Mar 10, 2026. About 5 praise its link to the Planning Center database, about 7 say it is easy to set up and use, and 2 mention lower fees. Two mention duplicate profiles. One each mentions limited reporting or generosity tools, slow back-end processing of checks and scanning, trouble setting up recurring payments, and text-to-give location limits. Eight are positive and two are mixed. Across the page, 63% of ratings are five stars and 36% are four stars. The G2 page text we read showed no incentive marker, so we do not know whether any of the 10 were incentivized.

Two limits: we counted by hand, so a tally may be off by one or two, and Capterra and G2 are different sites, so 4.7 and 4.5 are not a head-to-head score.

What fees does each vendor list?

Rates as shown on each vendor's pricing page on Nov 9, 2026, 9:47 PM ET.

TithelyPlanning Center Giving (US)
Card2.9% + $0.302.15% + $0.30 per credit or debit card transaction
ACH bank transfer1% + $0.300% + $0.30
AMEX3.5% + $0.30Not listed here
International cardsNot listed here1.5% extra
Trial30 day free trial on all plansNot compared here

Sources for Tithely and Planning Center: Tithely pricing and Planning Center pricing. This table compares per-gift processing fees only. Monthly plan prices are in the next section.

Full-page capture of Planning Center's public pricing page showing the per-product price sliders, the Giving monthly total panel, the processing fee table by country and the pricing FAQ, with a privacy banner at the bottom.
Planning Center's public pricing page, full-page capture, Nov 9, 2026, 10:20 PM ET. Credit: Screenshot of Planning Center pricing page, Nov 9, 2026. Resized for web; no other changes.
The two top plan cards on Tithely's public pricing page: Free Online Giving at $0 a month plus standard processing fees, with no credit card required, and All-Access at $119 a month with a 30 day free trial.
Tithely's two top plans on its public pricing page, captured Nov 9, 2026, 10:20 PM ET. Credit: Screenshot of Tithely pricing page, Nov 9, 2026. It is the public pricing page, not a product screenshot, and the crop shows no named people or testimonials. Resized for web; no other changes.

What does each charge per month, before processing fees?

Planning Center sells Giving as a monthly subscription. Its pricing page says: "Pricing is based on the total number of donations given per month. Online payments are processed for a low, additional fee by Stripe." The default calculator view shows Giving as Free at 10 monthly donations, with a monthly total of $0 and "First 30 days free." The slider for the number of donations received per month lists these monthly prices:

Related: Stripe, PayPal or a giving platform: fees on a $100 gift

Donations per month (slider tier)Planning Center Giving, per month
10$0 (Free)
75$15
200$32
500$69
1,000$115
1,500$179
Unlimited$239

These are subscription prices, not the processing fees in the tables on this page. Tithely lists Free Giving at $0 a month plus standard processing fees, and its other plans at $19, $72, $89 and $119 a month. Tithely's plans are not priced by donation count, so the two lists do not line up tier for tier. Source: Planning Center pricing, opened Nov 9, 2026, 10:37 PM ET; Tithely pricing, seen Nov 9, 2026, 9:47 PM ET.

How much is the fee on a $100 gift?

Here is the arithmetic from those rates. The fee is a percentage of the gift plus $0.30.

Gift of $100CalculationFee
Tithely, card2.9% of $100 = $2.90, plus $0.30$3.20
Tithely, ACH1% of $100 = $1.00, plus $0.30$1.30
Planning Center, card2.15% of $100 = $2.15, plus $0.30$2.45
Planning Center, ACH0% of $100 = $0.00, plus $0.30$0.30
Bar chart in three panels. Fee on a $100 gift: Tithely card $3.20, Tithely ACH $1.30, Planning Center Giving card $2.45, Planning Center Giving ACH $0.30. Tithe.ly on Capterra, 25 reviews read: low cost or value about 6, slow deposits to the bank 3, percentage fees heavy on very large gifts 1. Planning Center Giving on G2, 10 reviews read: easy to set up and use about 7, link to the Planning Center database about 5, lower fees 2, duplicate profiles 2.
The fee on a $100 gift at each vendor's logged rates, seen Nov 9, 2026, with the review points we read on Capterra and G2, hand counts accurate to about one or two. The two review sites are not a head-to-head score.

Fees only, for a made-up month

This is an illustration with made-up gift counts to show the arithmetic. It is not data from a church, and it leaves out each plan's monthly price: the totals below are processing fees only. Say a month brings 40 card gifts of $100 and 10 ACH gifts of $100, which is $5,000 in total.

IllustrationCard (40 gifts)ACH (10 gifts)Fees for the month
Tithely40 x $3.20 = $128.0010 x $1.30 = $13.00$141.00
Planning Center Giving40 x $2.45 = $98.0010 x $0.30 = $3.00$101.00

Swap in your own mix of card and bank gifts to see your own totals.

What the fee table does not tell you

  • It leaves out everything else you pay for. Tithely lists plans of Free Giving $0 a month, Website $19, Church Management $72, Mobile Church App $89 and All Access $119 a month. Planning Center Giving's monthly prices are listed in the section above. We did not compare what Planning Center charges for its other products.
  • "Free" does not mean no cost. Tithely's Free Giving plan is $0 a month, and the processing fees above still apply.
  • Planning Center's pricing page shows an "Apply for 12 months free" link. We did not read its terms, so this page does not describe that offer.
  • Reviewers on G2 often tie Planning Center Giving to the rest of Planning Center (about 5 of 10). If you do not use it for people records, that benefit does not apply to you.
  • Capterra reviewers of Tithe.ly mention slow deposits (3 of 25).

Who each one is NOT for

  • Tithely is not for you if the card and bank fee on the page is the only thing you are comparing. On the stated rates, Planning Center's is lower.
  • Planning Center Giving is not the obvious pick if you do not use Planning Center for anything else, since G2 reviewers often point to the integration.
  • Neither review set tells you how your church's mix of gifts will look. Use your own numbers.

What we could not confirm

  • What Planning Center's 12-month free offer covers.
  • Whether any of the G2 reviews we read, or any Capterra review, were incentivized. The G2 page text showed no marker.
  • What either vendor charges for products other than giving.
  • A real church's month of fees. The month above is an illustration.

If anything on the Tithely and Planning Center page is out of date, tell us about Tithely and Planning Center.

FAQ

Which has the lower card fee on a $100 gift?

Planning Center Giving: $2.45 (2.15% + $0.30) against Tithely's $3.20 (2.9% + $0.30), from each vendor's pricing page on Nov 9, 2026.

What does a bank transfer cost on a $100 gift?

$0.30 at Planning Center Giving (0% + $0.30) and $1.30 at Tithely (1% + $0.30).

Is Tithely's Free Giving plan really free?

The plan is $0 a month. Processing fees still apply: 2.9% + $0.30 by card and 1% + $0.30 by ACH. Tithely's page also offers a 30 day free trial on all plans.

Does Planning Center charge more for international cards?

Its pricing page lists 1.5% extra for international cards.

Keep reading

Sources for Tithely and Planning Center: Tithely pricing, Planning Center pricing, Capterra's Tithe.ly reviews, read for the Tithely and Planning Center comparison, G2 Planning Center Giving reviews.

When we will update the Tithely and Planning Center page

We will update it whenever either vendor changes a fee, and we re-read both fee pages monthly. We will also update it when we have a real, recorded month of fees to add.

Last checked: Nov 9, 2026 ET.

Ready to save time on the work that repeats every week?

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

Ready-to-use prompts for church administration, operations, planning, volunteer coordination, and practical staff workflows.

$6.99

One-time purchase · instant download

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

All 7 role-specific prompt packs for the work your church staff does every week—from pastoral care and administration to communication, youth, worship, and children’s ministry.

$24.99

One-time purchase · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →