Stripe or PayPal vs a Church Giving Platform: What a $100 Gift Really Costs

By Jake Thornhill•November 11, 2026•5 min read

Ministry Automation makes and sells the prompt packs linked on this page.

Two practical ways to get started with AI in your ministry

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

$6.99 · one-time purchase

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

$24.99 one-time · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →
The front and side of a light stone church with a green roof and a yard sign naming the church, in Elizaville, Indiana.
Elizaville Baptist Church in Elizaville, Indiana. A general photo of a church, not a church that uses any product named here. Credit: Elizaville Baptist Church, photograph by Nyttend, taken on 14 March 2015. Released into the public domain by the author (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:PD-self). Resized for web; no other changes.

Church giving fees: read Nov 9, 2026 ET. Where these giving numbers come from | Send a rate that looks off

TL;DR: On a $100 card gift, Stripe and Tithely each take $3.20, PayPal Checkout takes $3.98, PayPal's charity rate takes $2.48 once approved, and Planning Center takes $2.45 plus its monthly tier. Those are our sums on each provider's printed rates. Stripe's own page names no nonprofit rate.

What does a $100 gift cost on Stripe, PayPal, Tithely and Planning Center?

Start with the card rates printed on each provider's own page on Nov 9, 2026. Stripe's Standard pricing is 2.9% plus 30 cents per domestic card payment, and its page says there are no setup fees or monthly fees. Tithely's giving plan is $0 a month with 2.9% plus $0.30 on cards. Planning Center Giving charges 2.15% plus $0.30 on cards. PayPal Checkout is 3.49% plus a fixed fee of $0.49, and its charity rate is 1.99% plus the same fixed fee after PayPal approves the application.

Applied to one $100 domestic card gift with no donor covering the fee, that is $3.20 at Stripe, $3.20 at Tithely, $2.45 at Planning Center, $3.98 at PayPal Checkout and $2.48 at the PayPal charity rate. We worked these out ourselves from the printed rates and rounded to the cent.

Key takeaways

  • Planning Center has the lowest card rate here, but its monthly tier stacks on top once a church passes 10 gifts a month.
  • PayPal's charity rate lands near Planning Center's, and only after pre-approval.
  • Stripe has no monthly fee on its page and no nonprofit rate we could find.
  • This post adds Stripe and PayPal to the fee comparison already on our Tithely and Planning Center fee comparison.
Bar chart of the fee on one $100 domestic card gift, calculated from each published rate on Nov 9, 2026: PayPal Checkout $3.98, Stripe $3.20, Tithely $3.20, PayPal's charity rate $2.48 after approval, Planning Center $2.45 before its monthly tier.
What one $100 card gift costs at each provider, our arithmetic on the rates each one publishes (Nov 9, 2026). Stripe's nonprofit rate is not shown because we did not find one.
Stripe's Standard pricing card, showing 2.9% + 30 cents per successful transaction for domestic cards, with a Get started button.
Stripe's Standard card as captured Nov 9, 2026, 10:42 PM ET. Credit: Screenshot of Stripe pricing page (stripe.com/pricing), Nov 9, 2026, 10:42 PM ET.

What happens over a month of gifts?

A month of 40 card gifts of $100 each, $4,000 in all, with no donor covering the fee, comes to $128.00 at Stripe, $128.00 at Tithely, $159.20 at PayPal Checkout and $99.20 at PayPal's charity rate. Planning Center's cards cost $98.00 for the month, and 40 gifts sits in its tier that runs to 75 donations at $15 a month, so its month is $113.00. These are our sums; a real month will differ with gift sizes and the mix of cards and bank transfers.

What about bank transfers?

On a $100 ACH gift, Tithely lists 1% plus $0.30, so $1.30, and Planning Center lists 0% plus $0.30, so $0.30. We did not read the Stripe or PayPal bank transfer fees, so they are not compared here.

What is the catch with each?

Stripe adds 0.5% for manually entered cards, 1.5% for international cards and 1% when a currency has to be converted. Its nonprofits page returned a 404 for us, so we cannot say whether a church can get a lower rate.

PayPal Checkout is the most expensive of the five at $3.98 on a $100 gift. The charity rate of 1.99% is "subject to eligibility, application, and pre-approval by PayPal", and international charity gifts add 1.50%.

Tithely charges 3.5% plus $0.30 on American Express, which makes that $3.80 on $100, and the page lists its card and bank rates in separate lines.

Planning Center's lower rate is paired with a monthly tier, from $15 for up to 75 gifts a month to $239 at the top, and it is free only up to 10 gifts a month.

What did we not check?

  • A Stripe nonprofit rate; the page we tried was not found.
  • Payout timing, chargeback or dispute fees, and bank transfer fees at Stripe and PayPal.
  • Donor-covers-the-fee options and how each provider words them.
  • Receipts and year end tax statements.
  • Any real donation flow. We read pricing pages and did the arithmetic; no test donation was made.

FAQ

Which is cheapest for a $100 card gift?

Planning Center at $2.45, before its monthly tier. PayPal's charity rate is $2.48 once approved.

Does Stripe have a church or nonprofit rate?

We did not find one. Stripe's pricing page lists Nonprofits only as a menu item, and the page behind it returned a 404.

Does Tithely charge a monthly fee for giving?

Its giving plan is listed at $0 a month, with the card and bank rates above.

Keep reading

Rates came from Stripe's pricing page, PayPal's business fees page, Tithely's Giving plan page and Planning Center's pricing page, all opened Nov 9, 2026 ET.

Last checked: Nov 9, 2026 ET. Fees move, so open each page again before you choose.

Ready to save time on the work that repeats every week?

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

Ready-to-use prompts for church administration, operations, planning, volunteer coordination, and practical staff workflows.

$6.99

One-time purchase · instant download

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

All 7 role-specific prompt packs for the work your church staff does every week—from pastoral care and administration to communication, youth, worship, and children’s ministry.

$24.99

One-time purchase · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →