Pushpay Alternatives for Churches: Published Rates From Tithely, Planning Center, Stripe and PayPal

By Jake Thornhill•November 11, 2026•5 min read

Ministry Automation makes and sells the prompt packs linked on this page.

Two practical ways to get started with AI in your ministry

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

$6.99 · one-time purchase

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

$24.99 one-time · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →
The stone tower and side wall of a church in Muncie, Indiana, under a clear sky, with an empty sidewalk in front.
The stone tower of First Baptist Church in Muncie, Indiana. A general photo of a church, not a church that uses any product named here. Credit: First Baptist Church in Muncie, photograph by Nyttend, taken on 7 January 2012. Released into the public domain by the author (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:PD-self). Resized for web; no other changes.

Pushpay alternatives: pages read Nov 9, 2026 ET. How these rate reads are made | Flag a rate that has changed

TL;DR: Pushpay's pricing page lists no plan price and offers a demo. Tithely, Planning Center, Stripe and PayPal's charity rate each print theirs, from $0 a month for Tithely's giving plan to a $239 top tier at Planning Center. We found no source that says which one fits a church under 500 members, so the rates are laid out for you to compare.

Which Pushpay alternatives publish their prices?

Four do, on their own pages read Nov 9, 2026. Tithely Giving is $0 a month plus card and bank processing. Planning Center Giving is free up to 10 donations a month and then steps from $15 to $239. Stripe lists 2.9% + 30 cents per domestic card transaction. PayPal lists a charity rate of 1.99% plus a fixed fee after pre-approval. Pushpay's pricing page shows no dollar plan price and invites you to request a demo.

Key takeaways

  • Pushpay's page lists no plan price, so its cost is a question for its sales team. The only price it prints is check scanning, from $0.29 a check.
  • Tithely's giving plan has no monthly fee; its cost sits in the processing rates.
  • Planning Center's monthly fee depends on how many donations arrive in a month.
  • Stripe and PayPal publish a per-transaction rate and no monthly giving fee on the pages we opened.
Bar chart of monthly giving fees read Nov 9, 2026. Tithely's Free Giving plan is $0 a month. Planning Center Giving is $0 up to 10 donations a month, then $15 up to 75, $32 up to 200, $69 up to 500, $115 up to 1,000, $179 up to 1,500 and $239 for unlimited. Pushpay lists no plan price, so it has no bar.
Monthly fee for giving at Tithely and Planning Center before card or bank processing, read Nov 9, 2026. Pushpay's pricing page shows no plan price.
The top of Pushpay's pricing page, with the heading For every church size and budget and an offer of a free, no obligation demo, and no plan price in view.
Pushpay's pricing page as captured Nov 9, 2026, 10:26 PM ET. It shows an offer of a demo and no plan price. Credit: Screenshot of Pushpay pricing page (pushpay.com/pricing), Nov 9, 2026, 10:26 PM ET.

What does Pushpay's own page show?

As of Nov 9, 2026, Pushpay's pricing page lists no plan price and invites you to "get a free, no obligation demo". Its one printed price is check scanning, which "starts at $0.29 per check". The page heading says it is "for every church size and budget"; that is Pushpay's own claim, and we found no source that tests it.

We did not find Pushpay's fees, contract terms or any minimum on that page. A church comparing it with the others has to ask for those in writing.

What do the four alternatives publish?

OptionMonthly feeCard rateBank (ACH) rateA cost to weigh
Tithely Giving$02.9% + $0.301% + $0.30American Express is 3.5% + $0.30
Planning Center Giving$0 to 10 donations, then $15 to $2392.15% + $0.300% + $0.30the monthly fee rises with donation count
Stripenone stated on the page2.9% + 30 cents, domesticnot readthe card rate matches Tithely's, with no church tools described
PayPal charity ratenone stated on the page1.99% + a fixed feenot readthe rate applies only after pre-approval

Sources: Tithely, Planning Center, Stripe and PayPal, each read Nov 9, 2026. Planning Center's tiers read: $15 up to 75 donations, $32 up to 200, $69 up to 500, $115 up to 1,000, $179 up to 1,500 and $239 for unlimited.

What does a $100 gift cost on each?

On a $100 domestic card gift, with no fee covered by the donor and no Planning Center monthly tier added, the printed card rates work out to $3.20 at Tithely and at Stripe, and $2.45 at Planning Center. That is our arithmetic on the rates above, not a quote from any vendor. Planning Center's monthly tier comes on top, so a church that receives 200 gifts a month adds its $32 tier to the processing. Whether one platform costs less for your church depends on gift sizes and counts, and we have no church's data to say. Our longer comparison of two of these is in Tithely and Planning Center, fee by fee.

Do any of these fit a church under 500 members?

No source we read states a fit by church size, so we do not make that claim. What the pages do show is where the counts sit: Planning Center's $69 tier covers up to 500 donations a month and its top tier is unlimited, while Tithely's giving plan has no monthly fee at any size. Pushpay says it serves every size, which we could not check.

What did we not check?

  • Pushpay's fees, minimums and contract terms, which its pricing page does not print.
  • Written reviews of Pushpay's giving product; we opened none.
  • Whether anyone can use PayPal's charity rate; the page says it needs approval.
  • A hands-on setup of any of them. We made no signup, and this page rests on public pages.

What should you ask before you move?

Ask Pushpay for its fees and terms in writing, since the page gives none. For Planning Center, count how many donations you receive in a typical month and find the tier. For Tithely, ask what your church's processing would be at your mix of cards and bank transfers. If you also want accounting and automation, see church accounting software and church giving automation before you pick a giving tool.

FAQ

Does Pushpay publish a price?

Not a plan price on the pricing page we read. It lists check scanning from $0.29 a check and offers a demo.

Is Tithely's giving plan really $0 a month?

Its page lists Free Giving at $0 a month, with processing at 2.9% plus $0.30 on cards, 1% plus $0.30 on ACH and 3.5% plus $0.30 on American Express.

Can a church get PayPal's charity rate?

PayPal lists 1.99% plus a fixed fee for charity transactions after pre-approval, so the rate is not automatic.

Keep reading

Pages behind each rate, dated Nov 9, 2026 ET: Pushpay's pricing page, Tithely's giving plan page, Planning Center's pricing page, Stripe's pricing page and PayPal's business fees page.

Last checked: Nov 9, 2026 ET. Rates change, so read each page again before you switch.

Ready to save time on the work that repeats every week?

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

Ready-to-use prompts for church administration, operations, planning, volunteer coordination, and practical staff workflows.

$6.99

One-time purchase · instant download

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

All 7 role-specific prompt packs for the work your church staff does every week—from pastoral care and administration to communication, youth, worship, and children’s ministry.

$24.99

One-time purchase · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →