Pushpay vs Tithely for Churches: What Each Charges and What Pushpay's Reviewers Say

By Jake Thornhill•November 11, 2026•5 min read

Ministry Automation makes and sells the prompt packs linked on this page.

Two practical ways to get started with AI in your ministry

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

$6.99 · one-time purchase

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

$24.99 one-time · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →
Timber-framed parish church with a red-tile roof and a blue church sign, seen across a lawn.
St John's parish church, High Legh, a timber-framed church with a red-tile roof, a blue parish sign, and a memorial stone in the foreground. Credit: St John's parish church, The Avenue, High Legh, Cheshire, seen from the southwest, photograph by Whatlep, 5 October 2009. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:High_Legh_Parish_Church_-_geograph.org.uk_-_1522518.jpg

Pushpay and Tithely: pages read Nov 11, 2026 ET. How the Pushpay and Tithely reads were done | Report a mistaken price or count

TL;DR: Pushpay publishes no plan price and invites you to book a demo. Tithely prints five, from $0 a month for Free Giving to $119 for All Access, with card and bank processing on top. On Capterra, Pushpay is rated 4.2 from 183 reviews, and of the 25 most helpful ones we read, about 16 praise easy giving and about 10 mention cost or fees. We found no review set for Tithely, so the reviews side of this page is Pushpay only.

How do Pushpay and Tithely compare on price and reviews?

Pushpay is quote based: its pricing page, read Nov 11, 2026, lists no plan prices and offers "a free, no obligation demo for answers and pricing options." A check scanning add-on "starts at $0.29 per check," which is not a plan price. Tithely's page lists five plans: Free Giving at $0 a month, Website at $19, Church Management at $72, Mobile Church App at $89 and All Access at $119. Card payments run at 2.9% + $0.30, ACH at 1% + $0.30 and American Express at 3.5% + $0.30. It also says all plans include free giving and a 30 day free trial.

Key takeaways

  • You cannot compare Pushpay's price with Tithely's from public pages, because Pushpay prints none.
  • Tithely's $0 giving plan still has processing fees, so $0 a month is not $0 in total.
  • Cost or fees is the most common complaint in the Pushpay reviews we read: about 10 of 25 on Capterra, and about 8 of 25 on Software Advice.
  • Many Software Advice reviews are marked as invited with a nominal incentive.
  • We have no source for how either product fits a church over 500 members, so this page makes no size claim.
Bar chart of Pushpay's 183 ratings on Software Advice, read Nov 11, 2026: 97 five-star, 57 four-star, 13 three-star, 3 two-star and 13 one-star.
Pushpay's star split on Software Advice as counts. The same 183 reviews appear on Capterra, so they are one set, not two.
Pushpay pricing page headline offering a free demo for answers and pricing options, with no plan prices shown.
Official Pushpay pricing page as captured Nov 11, 2026, 9:20 AM ET, offering a demo for pricing options and listing no public plan price. Credit: Screenshot of the official Pushpay product pricing page, https://pushpay.com/product/pricing/, captured Nov 11, 2026, 9:20 AM ET. Resized for web; no other changes.

What do Pushpay's reviews say?

On Capterra, Pushpay is rated 4.2 from 183 reviews (last updated November 9, 2026), with ease of use at 4.3 and customer service at 3.8. We read the 25 most helpful reviews. About 16 praise ease of use, a simple giving experience, or easy online, text or QR giving. About 10 mention cost, fees or that the product is expensive. Customer service problems come up in about 4 or 5. One October 2024 review says donors cannot split one gift across funds. These counts are a hand count of the reviews we read, accurate to about one or two.

Software Advice shows the same 4.2 from 183, split 97, 57, 13, 3 and 13 from five stars down to one, with value for money at 3.6, functionality at 4.1 and customer support at 3.8. The two sites share a review catalog, so they are one set of reviews, not two. Of the 25 reviews on its first page, about half praise easy giving and about 8 raise cost, fees or contracts.

TrustRadius scores Pushpay 8.9 out of 10 from 16 reviews. We read 3 of them: two mention cost or fees, and one describes an inflexible annual contract. Three reviews are not a picture of the 16.

Are these reviews independent?

Not entirely. One Capterra review we read says the reviewer was invited by the vendor and received a gift card. On Software Advice, many reviews say the reviewer was invited and offered a nominal incentive, while one 2021 review says it was submitted organically with no incentive. One of the TrustRadius reviews is labeled incentivized. Capterra can drop that label, so an unlabeled review is not proof that none was given.

How much does Tithely cost?

The monthly prices above come straight from Tithely's own page, and processing is charged on top. Card gifts cost 2.9% + $0.30, ACH 1% + $0.30 and American Express 3.5% + $0.30. On a $100 card gift, that fee is $3.20, which is our arithmetic.

What is the catch with each?

Pushpay: no plan price is public, so a church has to book a demo to learn what it would pay, and cost is the most common complaint in the reviews we read.

Tithely: the free giving plan carries processing fees on every gift, and the other plans add $19 to $119 a month. We found no review set for Tithely on these pages, so we say nothing about what its customers think.

What did we not check?

  • Pushpay's plan prices, which none of the pages list.
  • Reviews of Tithely. We did not collect any.
  • Tithely's referral payout and anything about its program; this page has no Tithely link.
  • A usable G2 review set for Pushpay giving. G2's Pushpay link opens a different product page, ChurchStaq, so we use no G2 rating.
  • Any fit for a church over 500 members, and how either product performs for one.
  • Both vendors' own comparison pages. We did not open them.

FAQ

How much does Pushpay cost?

Its pricing page lists no plan price and offers a free demo. The one dollar figure on the page is a check scanning add-on starting at $0.29 a check.

What is Pushpay's rating?

4.2 from 183 reviews on Capterra and Software Advice (one shared set), and 8.9 out of 10 from 16 on TrustRadius, all read Nov 11, 2026.

Is Tithely free?

Its Free Giving plan has no monthly fee, but card and bank gifts carry processing fees.

Keep reading

Pages read Nov 11, 2026 ET: Pushpay's pricing page, Pushpay on Capterra, Pushpay on Software Advice and Pushpay on TrustRadius, plus Tithely's pricing page at get.tithe.ly/pricing.

Last checked: Nov 11, 2026 ET. Review counts and prices move, so open each page again before you decide.

Ready to save time on the work that repeats every week?

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

Ready-to-use prompts for church administration, operations, planning, volunteer coordination, and practical staff workflows.

$6.99

One-time purchase · instant download

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

All 7 role-specific prompt packs for the work your church staff does every week—from pastoral care and administration to communication, youth, worship, and children’s ministry.

$24.99

One-time purchase · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →