Planning Center Alternatives for a Small Church: G2 Ratings and Published Prices, Read Nov 9, 2026

By Jake Thornhill•November 10, 2026•5 min read

Ministry Automation makes and sells the prompt packs linked on this page.

Two practical ways to get started with AI in your ministry

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

$6.99 · one-time purchase

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

$24.99 one-time · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →
A brick church with a steep roof and a cross, standing in light snow.
A brick church with a steep roof and a cross, in snow. A general photo of a church, not tied to any product on this page. Credit: St. John Lutheran Church, Youngstown, New York, photograph by Andre Carrotflower, 28 January 2023. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/). Via Wikimedia Commons. Unchanged original, not cropped or edited. File page: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:St._John_Lutheran_Church,_Youngstown,_New_York_-_20230128.jpg Resized for web; no other changes.

Planning Center alternatives: last checked Nov 9, 2026 ET. The site behind these notes | Correct a rating or price on this page

What can a small church use instead of Planning Center, and what do they cost?

On G2's church management category page, read Nov 9, 2026, the products listed beside Planning Center include Churchteams, Jios Apps, Gracely, Church Community Builder (listed under Pushpay) and Subsplash. We could read a price on a vendor page for only two products here. Planning Center People is free for unlimited users, and Tithely Church Management is $72 a month. Church Community Builder's price is not published on Pushpay's pricing page, and for Churchteams, Jios Apps, Gracely and Subsplash we did not read a price, so those cells say so. We do not say which option suits a small church, because G2 does not list church size by product.

Key takeaways

  • Ratings from G2 on Nov 9, 2026 run from 4.0 for Church Community Builder (117 reviews) to 4.9 for Jios Apps (39) and Gracely (21).
  • The review counts differ a lot, from 21 to 181, so a rating is not comparable to another without its count.
  • Planning Center People is free for unlimited users; Tithely lists People as "a simple, free way to track member info that syncs directly with your giving data."
  • Tithely Church Management is listed at $72 a month; Free Giving is $0 a month and the 30 day free trial is on all plans.
  • Four prices were not read, and this page does not rank products by rating.
Two plan cards from Tithely's pricing page: Free Online Giving priced at $0 a month and All-Access priced at $119 a month.
Two of Tithely's plan cards, captured Nov 9, 2026, 10:20 PM ET. The $72 Church Management plan discussed below is not in this image. Credit: Screenshot of https://get.tithe.ly/pricing, captured Nov 9, 2026 10:20 PM ET. Page and marks belong to Tithely.

What do the G2 ratings show?

These are aggregate ratings from G2's church management category page, read on Nov 9, 2026. The page title says "User Reviews from November 2026" and a guide section on it says "Updated October 3, 2024", so we cite the rating date we saw, not the guide date. We read ratings and counts only, and no written reviews from this page.

Product on G2RatingReviews
Planning Center People4.850
Planning Center Services4.7181
Planning Center Groups4.424
Churchteams4.7117
Jios Apps4.939
Gracely4.921
Church Community Builder (listed under Pushpay)4.0117
Subsplash4.234

G2 lists products, not editions, and a few rows on the page showed no product name in the text we read, so we left those out. The same list also holds two texting tools, Clearstream at 4.8 from 191 and Text In Church at 4.8 from 32, which add texting to a database and are not replacements for Planning Center. G2's own summaries mention ease of use, integrations and support, and note that Planning Center Services can feel overwhelming for new users. Those summaries are G2's, not our count.

Bar chart of G2 church-management ratings and review counts, read Nov 9, 2026, about 10:30 PM ET. Planning Center Services 4.7 from 181, People 4.8 from 50, Groups 4.4 from 24, Churchteams 4.7 from 117, Jios Apps 4.9 from 39, Gracely 4.9 from 21, Church Community Builder 4.0 from 117, Subsplash 4.2 from 34, Clearstream 4.8 from 191, and Text In Church 4.8 from 32. Sample sizes are not equal.
G2 category page Best Church Management Software, Nov 9, 2026, about 10:30 PM ET. Sample sizes differ.

What does each one cost on its own page?

ProductWhat its own page says, read Nov 9, 2026
Planning Center PeopleFree for unlimited users; always free member database, reporting and communication
Tithely Church Management$72 a month; Website $19, Mobile Church App $89, All Access $119, Free Giving $0; "All plans include free giving plus a 30 day free trial"
Church Community BuilderNot published: Pushpay's pricing page shows no dollar plan prices
ChurchteamsNot read
Jios AppsNot read
GracelyNot read
SubsplashNot read

Church Community Builder's own address now redirects to Pushpay's site. Third-party pages quote prices for it, and we did not use them.

Which alternative fits a small church?

We cannot say from what we read. G2 does not break its ratings down by church size, so the only fit we can state comes from vendor plan scope: People is free for unlimited users, and Tithely lists People as free to track member info. Neither fact tells you whether a product handles your volunteers, giving or check-ins.

Who is this page not for?

This page is not for anyone choosing on price alone, since four prices are missing. It is also not a test, because we made no account anywhere.

What did we not check?

  • Prices for Churchteams, Jios Apps, Gracely and Subsplash.
  • Which product suits a small church.
  • Written reviews behind the ratings, and incentive status of any review.
  • Any discussion on Reddit, which we could not open.

Questions to ask before you switch

  1. Which job do we need the replacement to do: member records, scheduling, giving or check-ins?
  2. What does each vendor charge for our size, on its own page, today?
  3. How many reviews sit behind a rating we are relying on?
  4. Can we export our records from Planning Center before we leave?

FAQ

What is a free alternative to Planning Center?

Planning Center's own People module is free for unlimited users. Tithely's pricing page lists a free way to track member info and a Free Giving plan at $0 a month, both read Nov 9, 2026.

Which alternative has the highest G2 rating?

Jios Apps and Gracely both show 4.9 on G2, from 39 and 21 reviews. Those are small counts, so we do not call either one the best.

Does Church Community Builder publish its price?

Not on the Pushpay pricing page we read on Nov 9, 2026, which shows no dollar plan prices.

Keep reading

Where the figures came from, all read Nov 9, 2026 ET: G2's church management category, the Pushpay pricing page, Planning Center pricing and the Tithely pricing page.

Last checked: Nov 9, 2026 ET. Prices and ratings change, so confirm them on the vendor's own page.

Ready to save time on the work that repeats every week?

Quick start

Executive Pastor AI Prompt Pack

Ready-to-use prompts for church administration, operations, planning, volunteer coordination, and practical staff workflows.

$6.99

One-time purchase · instant download

Get the Executive Pastor Pack →
All staff roles

Complete Church Staff AI Bundle

All 7 role-specific prompt packs for the work your church staff does every week—from pastoral care and administration to communication, youth, worship, and children’s ministry.

$24.99

One-time purchase · all 7 role packs

Get the Bundle →